• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Gotta Getta Bagel

At Gotta Getta Bagel, located in the heart of New York City, bagels are more than just food; they are a passion. Our story revolves around a commitment to quality and community. Offering a cozy atmosphere with casual dining, we invite patrons to enjoy a variety of freshly baked bagels, delicious breakfast platters, and vibrant salads. With something for everyone—including numerous vegetarian options—our establishment is family-friendly and accessible. We pride ourselves on fast service, delightful flavors, and a true New York experience. Come for the bagels, stay for the atmosphere, and leave with lasting memories.

Gotta Getta Bagel: Reviews & Ratings

Phil H.
Phil H.

Being in search of the best bagel in Nu Yawk ya gotta eat a lot of 'frogs' before you find your 'prince' of bagels. I know, that was a bad joke. Anyway this is no top 10. My everything with cream cheese while cooked to the right amount of goldenness was a tad chewy. Cream cheese was a little thin and mushy. I give BB credit for quick service, decent price. They have a few tables to sit at inside but nothing outside to watch the world go by. That's always a nice thing. Will I go back? As I have said in other reviews, too many other choices in NYC. If you live in the neighborhood, yeah, ok. See my video review of BB and other places in NYC on instagram @bagelmavennyc

Marianne W.
Marianne W.

Bagel Boss has huge thick doughy bagels. I can freeze them and take one out after a couple months and it's just as soft and fresh tasting as if it came out of the oven. I have to slice one in half and save half for the next day. I typically buy the Whole Wheat Everything and add my favorite cream cheese. This location is classic style NYC seating and service. If I lived in the neighborhood I'd be here for coffee and bagels frequently. If you happen to be nearby I suggest you pick up bagels to take home or to your office. They're so very good!

Location

Welcome to Gotta Getta Bagel, a delightful haven for bagel lovers at 263 1st Ave., New York, NY 10003. This bakery is more than just a place to grab a quick bite; it's an experience steeped in the rich tradition of New York's iconic bagel culture. With its casual atmosphere and varied menu, Gotta Getta Bagel caters to everyone—from busy professionals to families seeking a delicious meal.

  • Accessibility: Gotta Getta Bagel is wheelchair accessible and provides outdoor seating options, making it an inviting choice for all diners.
  • Connectivity: Guests can enjoy free Wi-Fi while savoring their meals, allowing for a relaxed dining experience or even a casual work session.
  • Culinary Offerings: The menu boasts substantial vegetarian options alongside classic bagels, savory omelettes, and mouthwatering smoked fish sandwiches.
  • Breakfast and Lunch: The breakfast omelettes are a standout feature. For just $12.99, you can indulge in a 3 Eggs and Vegetables Omelette, paired perfectly with your choice of bagel or bialy. Fancy something more indulgent? Try the Leo Omelette with lox for $13.99—a worthy treat for any brunch lover.
  • Texture and Taste: Patrons rave about the thick, doughy bagels. Many note that even when frozen, a Gotta Getta Bagel maintains its soft, fresh quality. This testament to quality indicates the dedication and craftsmanship behind each product.
  • Specialties: For a true taste of New York, don't overlook the Master Smoked Fish Sandwiches. At $17.99, you can relish the Smoked Atlantic Nova Lox Sandwich, artfully crafted with crisp lettuce, tomatoes, Bermuda onions, and rich cream cheese.
  • Sweets: Save room for dessert! The rice pudding and chocolate pudding, both priced at $6.50, promise to satisfy any sweet tooth.

As you step into Gotta Getta Bagel, the aroma of freshly baked goods invites you to stay awhile. The moderate noise level and casual dining space provide the perfect backdrop for a lively breakfast gathering or lunch with friends. With credit cards and Apple Pay accepted, your convenience is a priority here. Plus, outdoor seating offers a chance to soak in the vibrant NYC scene while enjoying exceptional food.

Customer reviews echo the charm and quality of Gotta Getta Bagel. It’s clear that while the establishment stands among many in the city, it holds its own with its hearty offerings and friendly service. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Gotta Getta Bagel indeed makes for a memorable stop in the Big Apple!